Menu
Arendal Sound
  • Register
  • Log In
  • Login/Register
  • SUBWOOFERS
  • TOWER SPEAKERS
  • MONITOR SPEAKERS
  • CENTER SPEAKERS
  • BOOKSHELF SPEAKERS
  • HEIGHT/ATMOS SPEAKERS
  • SURROUND SPEAKERS
  • STANDS

Homepage / Community / Technical questions / Sticking with 5.1 layout vs squeezing in 7.1?

Sticking with 5.1 layout vs squeezing in 7.1?

chris-lukowski
Community Member

Hi Everybody, I’ve hit a snag in my layout planning and need some advice. Attached are some pictures of my room and a SketchUp of what I plan to do. I’m 70% confident that sticking with a 5.1 layout would result in better sound, but the part that isn’t sure is really nagging me. Relevant stats posted below. My rear wall isn’t ideal due to the fact that it’s an entryway, has a coat rack, and a staircase all right there. What concerns me most is whether I can give the speakers the right positioning that 1) won’t make my bed layer sound worse and 2) won’t muddle the channel separation with my in ceiling Atmos speakers, especially if they’re mounted too high. In particular I’m worried that the upmixing from my AVR for 5.1 or 2.1 sources will amplify any placement or speaker choice issues* vs content with actual Surround Back content. Finally I’ve read in a few places that 7.1 layouts should only be used for rooms 350sqft or more, and mine is 241sqft not counting the open concept areas (which should only matter for the subs I assume). Should I even be considering this or is FOMO getting to me? If surround backs won’t make much difference or will make things worse for an area like this let me know. Or tell me it’s with it if that’s your assessment. Thanks!

* Even though I really want 1723 S Surrounds for my sides I don’t think I have the space for them in the back. I need clearance for my entry door to open and also body clearance for entering / exiting the staircase. The 1961 Surrounds and Bookshelves are narrower but also stick out more. From a design standpoint I’m not sure any wall mounted speaker won’t stick out like a sore thumb, making things lean towards just sticking with 5.1

Living Room Area Dimensions: 11.5’W x 21’L x 8’H (extended window well on left, open to dinette area on right)

MLP: 13’ from front wall, 38” high

Planned 5.1 Speakers: 1723 S Monitors & Surrounds, 1723 1V Subwoofers

Side Surround: 67.5” MLP center to side walls, distance to baffle from main seats more like 46”, 100° angle from MLP center, height 46”-61” bottom to top

Back Wall: 100” distance, maximum speaker separation 48” for ~165° position each, coat rack 68” off of floor & 40” wide

Attachments:
July 9, 2023 at 21:25

All replies (19)

1 2 →
Michael
Community Member

I kind of have the same room where it doesn’t really have the size for 7 channel surround. I’m just doing the 5.2.4 and my ears seem to be having a good time. I think 5 channel surround is just fine. it’s the height/atmos that really makes my home theater come alive IMHO.

#45021 July 10, 2023 at 14:21
Luis Vazquez
Active Member

Unless you have a spare bedroom that you can use, I’m also thinking that 5.2.4 would be the better option in your space.

#45025 July 11, 2023 at 03:27
Lukas
Customer Support

Agree with Michael and Luis, keep the 5-channel bed layer.

You are sitting very close to the surround speakers, which means they will have a much more direct sound than the surround backs behind you. The surround back speakers will have more reflections from the room, as sound travels longer, and will create a mismatch between to sound characters. It will not sound balanced when effects are panning between the channels.
4 surround channels work best if you have the same distance to all of them.

#45031 July 11, 2023 at 09:25
chris-lukowski
Community Member

Thank you guys SO MUCH! I posted the same question on another audio forum and most people there were encouraging me to mount some Surround Backs on either side of the coat rack at about that height. Would have upped the project by $1200 with a pair of 1961 Heights and moving from a 5-channel to a 7-channel Emotiva XPA amplifier. I appreciate the vote of confidence in the 5.2.4.

Also FWIW unless Arendal has any surprises up their sleeve I plan to go with RSL C24E MKII’s for the in-ceiling Atmos speakers. The woofer baffles are aimed at 15° and the tweeters can be aimed at 30°. On-ceiling speakers like the 1961 Heights would stick out too much.

#45033 July 11, 2023 at 16:58
Lukas
Customer Support

The RSL speakers seem like a good choice. We have some customers using them and they match well from what I can tell.
No custom install products from us in the near future, unfortunately.

#45036 July 12, 2023 at 07:55
Luis Vazquez
Active Member

As Lukas indicated, those RSL speakers should be a very good choice.  Once things are in place and you have some time with the system, please let us know how things worked out for you.  Have fun and enjoy the journey…

#45045 July 15, 2023 at 17:12
Fsm1th5
Community Member

Sigh. You’re using sketchup… this is for you to figure it out.

Use the protractor and angles from the main listening position to see whether you can or not.

This is vital. 135-150 degrees from center which is 0.

Sides at 90-110.

For 5.1 surrounds at 110-120 degrees.

Now then onto height. Side surrounds up to 20 degrees elevation from ear level. And rear surrounds up to 25 degrees elevation.

 

Then you do your atmos placement based on those.

Starting from 45 degrees elevation. You can go up to 55 when the surrounds are elevated to compensate.

 

Please do your design on this information then post back with what you’ve come up with.

 

I trust this helps.

#45049 July 18, 2023 at 08:02
arkmann
Active Member

Chris good question.  I had a 7 speaker HT setup with 4 wall mounted surrounds. The 1st side pair was near the listening seats with 2 more surrounds further back.  Found that the 2 back surrounds added little so if I did it again I would go with just the 2 side mounts.  Is it possible to try and listen with just 5 and then add 2 more if you’re not happy?  Experimenting is part of the journey.  Let us know what you decide.  Good listening!

#45106 August 2, 2023 at 01:24
chris-lukowski
Community Member

Alright, one more question before I can put this question aside. IF I were to configure my back-of-couch furniture in such a way that makes surround back speakers aesthetically possible on stands, how far back would said surrounds (such as 1961 bookshelves) have to be in order to sound “as intended”, ie not calling undue attention to themselves by feeling like they’re blasting right into somebody’s ear? I see a lot of setups where the surrounds stands are right against the back of the couch and my gut feeling is that wouldn’t sound right, correct?

#45176 August 14, 2023 at 21:53
Lukas
Customer Support

Hi Chris,

Right against the couch is not great. I would give any speaker at least 5 feet of distance to the listener’s ears.

#45179 August 15, 2023 at 08:20
1 2 →
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
Log In

Don't have an account? Register now

Search

Similar Topics

Related posts:

  1. Placement of 1723 HEIGHT S speakers in ATMOS configuration
  2. Heights for surrounds vs regular surrounds
  3. 1961 bookshelf vs monitors in small/difficult room
  4. 1961 5.1 in a small room – 1723 center S THX?

Topic Categories

  • Technical questions
  • Showroom
  • Hangout
  • Ideas
  • Announcements

Latest Replies

  • Controversial choice or product?
  • Retire 1961 series
  • What receivers/amplifiers do you use to drive you Arendal setups?
  • Room Calibration ON or OFF?
  • Arendal 1723 S Set-Up

Topic Tags

#Arendal 1961 1 s #Arendal 1961 1v # 1v vs 1s 1723 1723 1s 1723 1V 1723 2S 1723 atmos 1723 Bookshelf S 1723 Center S THX 1723 Center THX 1723 Monitor S THX 1723 Monitor THX 1723 Speakers 1723 S Speakers 1723 THX 1723 Tower 1723 Tower S THX 1961 1961 1s 1961 1V 1961 Bookshelf 1961 Center 1961 monitors Ambassador amplifier Anthem Arendal 1961 1 s arendalsound Atmos bass better bass bookshelf branåsåinihelvete dual subwoofers EQ Feedback height marantz Monitor more bass oled Photos receiver Room correction setup Speaker placement Stand Options for 1723 Monitor Subwoofer surround speaker setup THX Tower
Arendal Sound
Trustpilot
© Copyright 2015-2024 Arendal Sound - All rights reservedCookie settings
Exciting News! We’ve transformed our Community into the exclusive Arendal Sound Club! Dive into a more engaging way to connect with fellow audio enthusiasts and enjoy special, members-only benefits. Best of all, you can continue using your existing credentials. Visit Club